New Zealand | Why 95% of AI Projects Fail and How to Join the Winning 5%

Rohan Salins - 28.08.202520250828

New Zealand | Why 95% of AI Projects Fail and How to Join the Winning 5%

Join our community of 1,000+ IT professionals, and receive tech tips and updates once a week.

Why 95% of AI Projects Fail and How to Join the Winning 5%

New Zealand | Why 95% of AI Projects Fail and How to Join the Winning 5%

The 95% Wake-Up Call 

MIT’s latest research delivered a sobering headline: 95 percent of enterprise generative AI pilots fail to deliver measurable business value. 

Executives across industries are beginning to admit the same reality. Their organisations have invested millions in AI pilots, chatbots, and transformation programs. Employees are experimenting with the technology. Yet when it comes time to report to the board, the measurable impact is absent. 

In contrast, a small minority of organisations are pulling ahead with extraordinary outcomes. Palantir grew U.S. commercial revenue by 64 percent year over year by embedding AI into decision workflows. ServiceNow achieved 21 percent subscription growth by wiring AI into cross-departmental automation. MidJourney has scaled to more than 200 million dollars in revenue with only 11 employees. Shopify has rebuilt its entire merchant experience with AI integrated into every workflow. 

These examples demonstrate that AI can create transformative results. The real question is why most companies remain stuck in failure mode while a few accelerate.

Six Reasons AI Projects Fail and How Leaders Can Respond

1. Organisational readiness is the real bottleneck

Most executives believe the success of AI projects hinges on which large language model they choose. In reality, the major obstacles are governance, workflow integration, and organisational ownership. Without clarity on who is responsible for risk management, how AI will fit into existing processes, and how change will be managed, projects stall before they scale. 

Successful organisations establish governance frameworks, clear ownership models, and human-in-the-loop guardrails before attempting to roll out AI broadly. Readiness is not an afterthought. It is the foundation. 

2. Problem selection is misaligned with value

Between 50 and 70 percent of AI budgets are directed toward front-office initiatives such as marketing copy generation, customer chatbots, and sales assistants. These projects often look impressive in demonstrations but provide limited measurable return. 

The data shows that the fastest path to impact lies in the back office. Functions such as claims processing, accounts payable and receivable, knowledge management, and workflow routing are repetitive, measurable, and high volume. They offer clear cost savings and efficiency gains. 

Organisations that focus their early efforts on back-office processes are far more likely to demonstrate undeniable value quickly.

3. Governance is introduced too late

Many organisations only consider governance after a pilot is already underway. By that point, risks related to bias, hallucination, and data leakage are already present. This reactive approach often leads to delays, reputational risk, and sometimes the abandonment of entire initiatives. 

The leaders who succeed embed governance into the design of the pilot itself. They conduct validation of model performance, fairness testing, and bias monitoring. They also establish escalation paths for errors and implement continuous monitoring from the very beginning. By treating governance as a design principle rather than a remedial measure, they create the conditions for scale.

4. Data is the hidden cost

It is estimated between 60 and 80 percent of AI project effort is spent on data preparation. Cleaning, structuring, securing, and integrating data pipelines is the hard work that makes AI systems useful. Yet most organisations fail to allocate sufficient budget or resources to this foundation. 

The organisations that succeed treat data as critical infrastructure. They invest in pipelines, governance, and quality assurance with the same seriousness they devote to cybersecurity or cloud platforms. In practice, the quality of the data determines the quality of the AI outcome.

5. Skills and alignment are more important than AI talent alone

Many companies believe they can solve their AI challenges by hiring more data scientists. But the failure of projects often comes not from a lack of technical expertise but from a lack of organisational alignment. 

Operations teams may not understand how AI will alter their processes. Compliance teams are often brought in too late. Product owners may lack the ability to evaluate AI outcomes. 

Successful companies build cross-functional teams combining IT, operations, compliance, and business leadership. They also invest in upskilling their existing staff in AI literacy, ensuring every department can contribute to adoption and innovation.

6. Expectations are unrealistic

Boards and executive teams frequently expect to see measurable return on AI investment within three to six months. The reality, meaningful returns often emerge after 12 to 18 months of iterative learning and scaling. 

This mismatch creates frustration and leads many leaders to prematurely declare failure. The most effective organisations reset expectations by establishing staged milestones. They begin by measuring cycle time reduction, then move to cost-to-serve improvements, and finally demonstrate margin expansion. By tying outcomes to clear business metrics, they sustain momentum and credibility.

7. Buy vs Build – Why Buying Wins More Often

MIT’s research reveals a striking truth: nearly two-thirds of companies investing in specialist AI tools succeed, compared with only one-third of those that try to build everything in-house. The takeaway is clear, building from scratch is a slow, risky and resource-heavy path which most organisations aren’t equipped for. The winners don’t waste years reinventing the wheel; they buy proven platforms for common functions and reserve internal development for the few areas where true competitive differentiation is possible.

What the 5% Do Differently

The organisations succeeding with AI are not necessarily more advanced technologically. They are more effective at adoption. Their secret is not in the models they choose but in how they rewire their people, workflows, and priorities to make AI an engine of business value. 

1. They focus narrowly, then scale broadly 

Instead of spreading efforts across ten pilots, the top performers pick one high-value use case, execute it with discipline, and prove measurable ROI. This credibility earns the mandate to expand into adjacent areas. MidJourney’s growth with a single, focused product is the clearest example of this principle at work. 

2. They embed AI into real workflows 

Most organisations showcase AI through demos and dashboards outside the flow of daily work. The winners do the opposite. They weave AI directly into core processes, customer support platforms, finance operations, supply chain systems, so the technology becomes invisible and indispensable. Palantir and ServiceNow exemplify this approach by building AI into the very fabric of decision-making and workflow automation. 

3. They enable the entire workforce 

The true differentiator between the organisations succeeding with AI and those failing is not the sophistication of their models but the readiness of their people. Too many projects collapse because employees either do not understand the tools or do not trust them, leading to slow adoption and wasted investment. 

The winning organisations take the opposite approach. They treat AI as a company-wide capability rather than an IT experiment. Every employee, from the back office to the front line, is enabled to apply AI in daily work. This broad base of literacy accelerates adoption, surfaces valuable use cases from unexpected parts of the business, and transforms scepticism into momentum. 

In the same way digital literacy became a baseline requirement during the internet era, AI literacy is rapidly becoming the foundation of competitive advantage. Companies failing to equip their workforce with these skills will find themselves repeating the mistakes of those who ignored digital transformation 15 years ago and risk being left behind just as quickly. Discover how leading organisations are enabling their entire workforce to become AI literate in just 75 minutes with the Generative AI Sprint 1.   

4. They measure outcomes leadership actually care about 

Executives and boards are not persuaded by statistics like “number of chatbot users.” They want evidence of margin expansion, cycle-time compression, cost-to-serve reduction, or risk mitigation. The winning five percent design their AI initiatives to track business outcomes, not vanity metrics, and they tie progress directly to financial and operational KPIs. 

5. They invest in back-office automation before chasing front-office excitement 

The majority of companies spend their AI budgets on customer-facing experiments which rarely scale. The leaders invert this logic. They start with repetitive, measurable back-office functions such as claims processing, payroll, or compliance workflows, where automation delivers undeniable value. This creates a foundation of trust and momentum before venturing into more complex front-office use cases. 

6. They accelerate the operating cadence 

Organisations stuck in the 95 percent operate on quarterly cycles, steering committees, and delayed feedback loops. The successful five percent operate on an entirely different rhythm. They push updates weekly, track adoption daily, and provide executives with real-time dashboards. By collapsing the cycle from months to days, they allow AI systems to learn, adapt, and compound value far faster than traditional structures allow. 

The common thread across all of these behaviours is cultural, not technical. The winning organisations treat AI as a capability every employee must master, not a tool for a specialist few. They focus on disciplined execution, embed AI into real workflows, measure value in boardroom terms, and operate at a cadence that matches the pace of technological change. 

The Insentra Generative AI Sprint Series

This is why Insentra created the Generative AI Sprint Series. It is not a strategy deck or a one-off pilot. It is a structured pathway to enable your workforce and achieve measurable outcomes. 

Sprint 1: The Art of the Possible with AI (Complimentary)  

Open your workforce’s eyes to what’s truly possible with AI. In this 75-minute session, employees explore tools such as Microsoft Copilot, ChatGPT, Google Gemini, Claude, and Insentra’s MIA (My Intelligent Assistant). The goal is to spark curiosity, remove fear, and inspire every employee from the back office to the front line to see how AI can transform their daily work.

(Perfect if you’re just starting out.)

Sprint 2: AI Mastery in Four Weeks  

Move beyond experimentation and into impact. Over four weeks, teams learn how to apply AI to their own data, automate repetitive processes, and embed AI directly into everyday workflows. The focus is on turning awareness into adoption so your workforce shifts from “knowing about AI” to actively using it to deliver measurable outcomes at scale. 

(For organisations ready to scale adoption)

Agentic AI Sprint: Launch in Ten Weeks 

For organisations ready to go beyond adoption, this sprint transforms a single idea into a market-ready AI-powered product in just ten weeks. With structured guidance, teams learn how to design, test, and launch AI-driven solutions even without a dedicated technical team. This is where your workforce moves from embedding AI into workflows to creating new value and innovation, turning employees into builders of the future.

(Ideal if you’re ready to innovate, not just adopt)

Final Word

The MIT statistic is a wake-up call. Ninety-five percent of AI projects are failing. But failure is not inevitable. 

The companies that succeed are not asking how to implement AI. They are asking a deeper question: Given one hundred times more intelligence, how should we rebuild our workflows, our teams, and our decisions? 

The starting point is clear. Organisations must train their people, align their processes, and embed AI into the flow of work. The fastest way to achieve this is to enable the entire workforce through structured programs designed for adoption. 

The 5 percent of companies that are succeeding have already taken this step. The question is whether you will join them. 

Hungry for more?

If you’re waiting for a sign, this is it.

We’re a certified amazing place to work, with an incredible team and fascinating projects – and we’re ready for you to join us! Go through our simple application process. Once you’re done, we will be in touch shortly!

Who is Insentra?

Imagine a business which exists to help IT Partners & Vendors grow and thrive.

Insentra is a 100% channel business. This means we provide a range of Advisory, Professional and Managed IT services exclusively for and through our Partners.

Our #PartnerObsessed business model achieves powerful results for our Partners and their Clients with our crew’s deep expertise and specialised knowledge.

We love what we do and are driven by a relentless determination to deliver exceptional service excellence.

New Zealand | SharePoint Online – Uploading and Managing Files

Insentra ISO 27001:2013 Certification

SYDNEY, WEDNESDAY 20TH APRIL 2022 – We are proud to announce that Insentra has achieved the  ISO 27001 Certification.